Illegal possession

Question

► Manisha devi vs ashok kumar court case Jameen 2 kanal h 2008 me kharidi thi tb se hi 1 kanal par ashok kumar agriculture karte hai or ek kanal par manisha devi kyuki 1 kanal ke pese papa ne diye the or ek kanal ke pese ashok ne lekin total 2 kanal jameen Manisha devi k naam par hai ab m jab apni 1 kanal me makaan banana chahta tha to unhone jhagda kar diya or mamla police station tak pahunch gya lekin lagbhag 10 din baad samjhauta hua ki 1 kanal ashok k naam karwa di jayegi or hame hamare makan banane de or is samjhaute par keval manisha ke bete or uske pati k signature hai Or mamla police station me hi samjhaute me sulajh gya lekin baad me unhone mujhe makan nhi banane diye Phir mene unpar courtcase kar diya ki jameen meri h puri 2 kanal or inhone illegal possession kar rkha hai Date mili Date par unke wakeel present hue bina power of attorney k To next date mili or kha ki power of attorney or ws file ki jaye Next date par unhone power of attorney to file kar di lekin ws file nhi kiya or uski jagah mediation file kar diya Mediation ki 4 dates lagi no one present on the dates finally mediation cancel Hui or ab court ki next date 06/05/2024 hai

Answer 1

In your case, although you currently have a procedural advantage due to the defendants’ failure to file a Written Statement within the prescribed time under the Code of Civil Procedure, 1908, your substantive claim has certain weaknesses that need careful handling. Since the entire 2 Kanal land is registered in Manisha Devi’s name, legal title prima facie vests with her, and your claim based on contribution of funds may face restrictions under the Prohibition of Benami Property Transactions Act, 1988 unless it falls within recognized exceptions. Additionally, your assertion of ownership over the entire land contradicts your earlier position of shared contribution, which may affect credibility. The police station settlement also lacks strong enforceability as it is neither registered nor signed by the title holder. Strategically, you should consider seeking relief limited to your 1 Kanal share and simultaneously move an application to close the defendants’ right to file their Written Statement, thereby strengthening your position procedurally while correcting substantive risks.

Illegal possession

1 Answer