1 Answer
Dear Client,
Sending a criminal defamation notice is not advisable. Your position is strong as a defendant, but weak as a complainant. Defamation (BNS Section 356) requires an imputation made to harm someone’s reputation. A legal notice that calls your posts defamatory is not itself defamatory, and the notice is a privileged communication so a complaint on that basis is unlikely to succeed. You said the company “has not substantiated its allegations”. There is no obligation on them to prove anything in reply to you. The burden of proof lies on whoever alleges.
However, the following are your defences if they sue or complain:
Truth for public good (Exception 1 to Section 356 BNS): Statements that are true and published for the public good are not defamatory. You will have to prove the truth.
Fair comment and good faith (Exceptions 2 and 9): Opinions on public conduct, and statements made in good faith to protect public interest are protected.
Court judgments and news reports: A fair and accurate report of judicial proceedings is protected, and Section 356 does not punish repeating what a court has actually said. Claims that went further than the orders may not be protected unless a court actually recorded this finding. If the court only noted allegations or an investigation, and did not find the company guilty, an unqualified statement of bribery can be harmful.
A defamation complaint has no strict limitation for a civil suit beyond the usual 3 years (Article 75, Limitation Act), and for a criminal complaint it is 1 year from the date of the offence (BNSS Section 514, earlier CrPC 468) for offences punishable up to 1 year. Since it is now over a year since their notice (October 2024), the risk of a criminal case on those old posts may have reduced. A civil suit may still be possible. Consider a civil legal notice only if they have caused you actual loss or harassment. Take the advice of an advocate before sending any notice.
I hope this answer helps. If you have any further queries, kindly do not hesitate to contact us. Thank you.